TobyMac Says He ‘Will Forever Be a Different Man’ After 21-Year-Old Son Truett’s Death

Christian musician TobyMac has built a successful career on making music from the heart — but after losing his 21-year-old son Truett nearly three years ago, his newest project is the most painfully personal yet.

“I will forever be a different man,” the star, 57, tells PEOPLE in this week’s issue of the ways in which his life has changed since Truett, an aspiring rapper, died of an accidental drug overdose in October 2019. “I thought, honestly, with my five kids and my bride, that I had the perfect life. And we’re really messy now. It’s not so neat anymore.”

Married to his college sweetheart Amanda, TobyMac (real name Kevin Michael McKeehan) and his twins Moses and Marlee, 20, and sons Leo, 17, and Judah, 16, have learned to live a new normal since Truett’s death, a journey that the star has chronicled in his searingly heartfelt new album Life After Death.

Taking stock of what he’s grateful for is something that TobyMac has always made an effort to do. In the wake of Truett’s death, the star is exceptionally thankful he was able to spend one last special moment with his son a week before he died, after Truett’s first live performance at a local venue in Franklin, Tennessee.

“I could not be more grateful [that I was there],” the musician says, noting that he was scheduled to fly out to Canada to tour that night before he rearranged his flight. “I’m just like, I have to be at his show. But in my mind he was going to do 20,000 other shows… I live across the street from where he did his last show and there’s a restaurant over there and some days I go to that restaurant and I just look over at the patio where I last saw him, and gave him a hug, and said, ‘I’m so proud of you,’ and I just cry.”

TobyMac says that he and Amanda were aware of Truett’s struggles with substance abuse, but never thought they would escalate the way they did. “It wasn’t something that we thought was OK, but we didn’t think it was an urgent problem, I guess,” he says. “I do think that he knew where we stood on it and wanted to honor us, so that was a battle that he fought.”

Though some studies indicate that couples may drift apart after the loss of a child, the seven-time Grammy Award winner says he and his wife’s bond has only grown stronger, as they’ve made an effort to be “more transparent” with one another.

That newfound transparency has spread to the entire McKeehan family, who now dedicate at least one or two nights a week to gathering around the fireplace and talking about whatever’s on their minds. It’s a practice that started when COVID first prevented them from going to church in person, but one that has prevailed in the years since.

“We just look each other in the eyes and talk about the hard things,” he says. “That’s been special to our family and needed… Truett was their hero, so it’s hard. Do we all know that he made a mistake? Absolutely. We all know what happened. My kids are aware, but it doesn’t tarnish the person that Truett is to any of us.”

TobyMac says the family has leaned heavily on their community and friends, including collaborator Jon Reddick, who came to the house the day after Truett died and played the piano, leaving the home awash in music. Reddick also helped TobyMac and his daughter Marlee pour their feelings into song on “Everything About You,” a deeply personal track that the star says felt “like some sort of therapy.”

His faith has also remained steadfast, and he cites a Bible passage — “God has rolled up his sleeves” — with giving him hope and allowing “little rods of light” to penetrate the darkness.

Amid the pain and the healing, Truett remains a steady presence, whether it’s through conversation or through the Truett Foster Foundation, which has so far put three young men through college via scholarships.

“We’re not scared to talk about it. It’s not a taboo subject. It’s something beautiful. [We have] the faith to believe, is Truett laughing at this right now? Is he saying, ‘Come on Dad, give him a break’ when I’m hard on his little brother? All that has been really good for us,” he says. “He’s part of an ongoing conversation. We meet every year at the park across the street where we had his service, and we tell stories about him — things he had done or said or made us laugh or when he was a bad boy or when he was so kindhearted. We remember him all the time.”