It’s (almost) the most wonderful time of the year for music fans: The Grammys. This includes the inevitable discourse that follows the award show. The Recording Academy already caught people’s ire when they announced their nominees for the 2024 awards ceremony last year, snubbing hip-hop releases in the general field, much to the dismay of rap fans. The show is scheduled to air on Sunday, February 4 at 8 PM ET on CBS so naturally, we’re asking two important questions: Who will probably walk away with a golden gramophone in the hip-hop and R&B categories, and who should win?
Of course, the difference here is that there are titans and underdogs in every race. Sometimes, the differentiating factor is quality, other times it’s commercial success, and we might even get a legacy pick here and there. In every case, there is more than one release worthy of a Grammy; sometimes, all of them are. Hopefully the Recording Academy proves us wrong when our answers differ
Best R&B Performance
- Chris Brown – “Summer Too Hot”
- Robert Glasper ft. SiR & Alex Isley – “Back To Love”
- Coco Jones – “ICU”
- Victoria Monét – “How Does It Make You Feel”
- SZA – “Kill Bill”
What Will Win: Are you ready to hear the coldest take you’ve ever heard in your life? Here goes nothing… it’s SZA’s “Kill Bill.” Sure, Chris Brown is also a superstar (and nominated again, somehow), but did his song take over the charts as much as Solana’s? “Back To Love” is peaceful harmony; is that as catchy and enveloping as killing your ex? While Coco Jones’ “ICU” is one of the sultriest songs of 2023, is its instrumental as unique in melody and timbre as Rob Bisel and Carter Lang’s production? Even though this is one of Victoria Monet’s best songs off of JAGUAR II, did it transcend fanbases like this SOS highlight did? No.
What Should Win: But let’s remember the category: Best R&B Performance. As far as vocals, Coco Jones steals the show, and everyone else is basically on par with SZA. That’s to say that “ICU” is probably the correct sleeper pick here if we’re going strictly off of typically captivating performances. But “Kill Bill” displays the TDE singer’s ability to switch cadences and pitches on a dime, multiple flows and melodic approaches, and a more infectious energy. Sorry to cop out on the first category, but we would love a SZA/Coco tie. But when it’s all said and done, “Kill Bill” is what will live on in the industry and with fans alike.
Best Melodic Rap Performance
- Burna Boy ft. 21 Savage – “Sittin’ On Top Of The World”
- Doja Cat – “Attention”
- Drake & 21 Savage – “Spin Bout U”
- Lil Durk ft. J. Cole – “All My Life”
- SZA – “Low”
What Will Win: Even though they’re commercial giants, Drake and 21 Savage might get the short end of the stick, thanks to the former’s reluctance to submit to the Grammys before. Then again, that could be exactly what makes them win trophies. But knowing the Recording Academy’s tendency to favor a mix of mainstream rap and classic hip-hop worship, Lil Durk and J. Cole’s “All My Life” is the front-runner. Doja Cat shines the most on “Attention” as a rapper, not a singer, and voters might think SZA already has her R&B and General Field categories in the bag. At least 21 has double odds, but the Burna Boy collab doesn’t have the same name recognition or hit potential.
What Should Win: That being said, as a mixture of melodic dexterity and traditional rap metrics, no track here is as balanced as “Sittin’ On Top Of The World.” The infectious bassline, the gritty drum beat, and 21 Savage’s refreshing approach to a more vintage instrumental contribute to this song’s ear-worm quality. Burna Boy is the star, and his calm but charismatic croons use plenty of different flows to match the shifting instrumentation. “All My Life” is more lyrical except for the chorus, “Spin Bout U” is a weak point on Her Loss in our eyes, and “Low”… well, “Low” is a jam, but a more melodic one than a fusion. So it’s a tight race, but “Sittin’ On Top Of The World” is truly the blend that this category represents.
